You want to find the best beaches in America? You need to head south. Way south.
Because they’re not where you think they are. They’re not in Florida, not in California, not in the Carolinas. They’re in the Caribbean.
Yes — America’s Caribbean. Places with names like St Croix and St Thomas and Culebra and St John. Where the sun hits different, the sand is a little softer, the water a little warmer, the air a little sweeter.
And yet somehow, these places remain under the radar. Maybe it’s the word “Caribbean” that throws people off. Maybe they forget that the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico are part of the American story too — just with better beaches. No currency exchange. No passport. Just a short flight to somewhere that feels like another world.
These aren’t just beaches. They’re sanctuaries. And they’re all a passport-free flight away. Here are our 10 favorite “American” beaches, all in the islands of the Caribbean. The 10 best beaches in America.
Trunk Bay, St John
You’ve seen this beach before. Maybe in a dream. Maybe on a postcard. Maybe just the way you imagine paradise should look. Trunk Bay is the crown jewel of Virgin Islands National Park — a perfect crescent of white sand, emerald green forest, and that endless, unbelievable blue. There’s an underwater snorkeling trail, but most people never even make it that far. You get here and you stay. Because it just might be the most beautiful beach in America.
Magens Bay, St Thomas
This is the classic. A mile-long arc of calm Caribbean water tucked into a protected bay. Magens is never in a hurry. There’s room to spread out, to float, to breathe. There’s a snack bar and paddleboards and families and honeymooners and locals who know this is the heartbeat of the island. If you want to understand St Thomas, start here. It’s one of a number of St Thomas beaches that are all world class.
Maho Bay, St John
This is the beach where sea turtles glide beneath you and pelicans skim the surface. Where the water is shallow and still and clear as air. Maho is for slow mornings and lazy afternoons, for floating and snorkeling and watching the world drift by. There’s a little beach bar across the road now, which makes it even harder to leave.
Turtle Beach, Buck Island, St Croix
You can’t get here by car. You take a catamaran or a little open boat and when you arrive, you realize why this place is protected. Buck Island is a national monument, a wild place with a reef full of life and an expanse of sand called Turtle Beach that feels untouched by time.
Playa Flamenco, Culebra
You walk through the palms and then it hits you: an endless white beach framed by mountains and nothing but turquoise water ahead. Playa Flamenco in Puerto Rico is as close to perfection as a beach can be. The waves roll in just gently enough. The colors are absurd. You buy pinchos from a kiosk, find a spot in the sand, and you stay until the sun melts behind the hills.
Sandy Point, St Croix
This is the edge of the world. A two-mile stretch of pure white beach that’s closed part of the year to protect nesting turtles. There’s no shade, no concessions, no noise. Just sand and sea and sky. You park at the end of a dirt road and walk until it’s just you and the Caribbean. If you’ve ever wondered what silence feels like, this is where you’ll hear it.
Lindquist Beach, St Thomas
Tucked into Smith Bay Park, Lindquist is what locals whisper about when they talk about the “real” St Thomas. It’s uncrowded, untouched, unreal. The sand is powdery white. The water turns from light turquoise to electric blue in seconds. There are picnic tables under the sea grapes and a stillness that feels like a secret.
Cane Bay, St Croix
This is where the divers go. But you don’t have to dive to fall in love with Cane Bay. The reef is just offshore, the palm trees lean toward the water, and there’s always someone strumming a guitar or sipping a rum punch from the beach bar. It’s casual, rugged, soulful — a little bit wild, a little bit perfect.
Brewers Bay, St Thomas
You land in St Thomas, and just minutes from the airport is this quiet, wide beach where locals come to grill and swim and spend Sundays in the sun. Brewers Bay is calm and uncrowded, with water so clear you can see the fish dancing around your ankles. The planes pass low overhead, but somehow it makes the place feel more peaceful, not less.
Protestant Cay, St Croix
There’s something about taking a boat to a beach — even if it’s just a one-minute ferry ride. Protestant Cay sits just offshore from downtown Christiansted, a little island with a beach club vibe and calm water all around. Order a cocktail, sink into the sand, and watch the sailboats drift across the harbor. This isn’t just the best beach near town. It’s one of the best-kept secrets in the Caribbean.
So yes — the best beaches in America are in the Caribbean. They’re wild and gentle, buzzing and quiet, remote and right-there.
They’re not just beaches. They’re proof that the Caribbean is still where America comes to dream.
Ask ChatGPT
